I just came from conducting a concert of my students from Harrison School for the Arts. They are a great group of high school students, but I often have to remind myself, they are high school students! The music that they played was challenging, and their playing was on a very high level, but the past week has been very stressful because their playing has not been consistent.
So when I got home this evening, my wife, Kathy, asked how the concert went, and I was able to tell her that they pulled it off! Kathy wondered out loud how it is that they were able to play well in the concert, but were so inconsistent in rehearsals. That set me to wondering, and I reached a conclusion, a kind of “aha!” moment.
As a professional player, I bring my “A” game to every rehearsal. When my instrument comes out of the case, I am giving all of my energy and all of my attention to the music and to my playing. When I perform with other professional players I take for granted that they will do likewise. But at some rehearsals the students played poorly, and in others they were outstanding. I couldn’t make sense out of how they could play well one day and poorly the next. The inconsistency in the rehearsals left me wondering if they were really up to the level required by the music. But faced with an audience, and with Mom, Dad, grandparents, and friends sitting in the house they played well. Then it occurred to me that the problem wasn’t that they couldn’t play the music. The problem was that they were not giving 100% at the rehearsals! They were not bringing their A Game.
So, when push came to shove these students were able to pull off a pretty impressive performance. But here is the problem. By not bringing their best to every rehearsal, these students were bringing an element of risk to the concert that is, to my way of thinking, unacceptable. They pulled it off this time, but can I be sure that they will the next? I can not! And as well as they played in the concert, how much better might they have played if they had been completely present at every rehearsal?
So it occurs to me that one of the differences between a group of talented kids and a group of seasoned professionals is this work habit. A pro gives 100% every time. Thinking back to a recent concert in which I played with Andrew York, he and I had two short rehearsals prior to the concert. During the first rehearsal we had little to say to each other (in a good way) to make the music better. We both played all the notes, all the rhythms, all the nuances, and played with each other. By the second rehearsal we were engaging each other in a real musical conversation, and by the concert, we were interacting deeply and playing off each other with conviction and passion. We were both confident in the playing because we had both been completely involved from the first note of the first rehearsal.
This is the quality that is missing in many student performances. As I said before, they are talented high school students, but they are high school students. So it is incumbent upon me as the teacher and as a professional to impart this work ethic on them.
I’ll make a point of having them read this blog, and hopefully they, and all of my readers will be inspired to consistently bring the A game to every practice and every rehearsal.